Monday, 14 March 2011

Gosh Extreme Art Eyeliner Vs L'Oreal Super Liner Carbon Gloss

My favourite eyeliner is undoubtedly Illamasqua Precision ink eyeliner however at £17 it is very pricey so I really wanted to see if there were any highstreet brand which offered a similar product. 
The two products I bought were Loreal Super Liner and Gosh Extreme Art eyeliner. I picked them both up at Superdrugs, I chose Loreal Superliner after seeing BeautyCrush's Drugstore favourites video and bought GOSH Extreme Art Liner after reading Moudly Fruit's review.
GOSH Extreme Art Eyeliner
Packaging is okay but seems a little cheap, the applicator is also not what I am use to as it is a brush instead of a foam like applicator.  Application isn't the easiest, due to the flimsy brush I found it a little hard to control but is extremely black and you get a good amount of product on the brush.
L'Oreal Super Liner Carbon Gloss
Packaging is really nice and sturdy, application tip is also great makes it easy to apply. This product would be great for beginers. This eyeliner is also really black but not quite as black as the GOSH one, it is also harder to draw an extra thin line with this eyeliner.
They both last quite well all day but the Loreal eyeliner does flake of a little easier and if you happen to rub your eye expect to be left with very little eyeliner. If you are a beginer to eyeliner I would really recommend the Loreal Super Liner as it is very easy to apply however if you are use to using liquid eyeliner I would recommend the GOSH Extreme Art Liner as it last a very long time and is extremely black!

Price wise Gosh is currently on offer at under £4 and the L'oreal one is £6.19.

Whats your favourite eyeliner?
Sabrina X

 photo homeeee_zps214aed0e.jpg


  1. This was a handy review, i've been looking for a high-street liquid eyeliner :)
    The Gosh one seems like a good one to try for only £4!

  2. i use the collection 2000 extreme felt tip liner, i really like that it's a pen rather than a brush, i'd be too clumsy with a brush!
    i like the eyeko graffiti liners too but don't have the black one so i don't use them too much.
    thanks for the review, may look into these!

  3. the gosh ones are amazing, i have to scrub ridiculously hard to get it off!

  4. I like the Eve Pearl liquid eyeliner. It stays on forever.

  5. I like the Eve Pearl liquid eyeliner. It stays on forever.

  6. Thanks for the tip, I've been wanting an eyeliner with a brush rather than a pen for a long time since the Natural Collection liquid eyeliner proved to be dire! Will hopefully get out to pick up the GOSH one while it's still on offer! xx

  7. Awesome review!!
    I'm currently using No7 liquid eyeliner and its amazing, lasts forever and is jet black and v easy to apply!

  8. I really don't like the GOSH ones. I bought 4 funky coloured ones, and they are so clumpy and thick!

  9. Hi I love the GOSH one and is easy to remove with an oil based makeup remover. But I am facing a massive dilemma with Superdrug not selling them as much and I fear they will discontinue the product and unavailable on the website. Anyone know where else I can purchase it? x